Mr. Handy wrote:
When he hears the news of Nathan Forbes being wounded by the beast, Reverend Trask asks the court to recess again and goes to visit him. "From your account, I believe you did harm the werewolf at least a little," he says. "The fact that it fled after being shot bears this out. It knew that you had the power to hurt it, so it took no chance in continuing to fight. Werewolves spend much of the time in human form, and from the locations of the attacks, I can deduce that the creature lives in the area. The damage caused by silver does not heal quickly. You must rest and recover, but I and the rest of the townsfolk can gather and examine everyone to see who has an injury in the same part of the body where you shot the beast. Then we shall have our werewolf. We could not have done this without your brave action."
Given Nathan's testimony as to the unnatural strength and vitality of the beast, the constabulary assembles a
posse comitatus (as it is understood in English law) to track down and destroy the monster. At first, this appears to be premature, as the predations cease for a time.
Many of the men of the town are ready to bear their chests, in order to prove that they do not show any such wound as is thought to appear upon the creature whilst in human form. It must be admitted, however, that others do not, for a variety of reasons. Some dismiss the whole idea as superstitious nonsense, despite the plain evidence that contradicts their opinion; others consider their position in society to be such that they will not lower their dignity in this manner; a few simply cannot be located, drifting as they do from one place to another. Whatever the case may be, as of yet the search does not reveal a positive result. The idea occurs to some the werewolf may be of the female sex, although it did not appear to be dressed in an appropriate way, and thus it cannot be thought of to apply the aforementioned examination.